A bit of background: I've been a phangirl since the summer I was 10, when two of the older campers at my camp started singing "Phantom of the Opera" in the courtyard at break. Anyway, this was a very exciting find for me. However, much to my dismay I remembered that I had spent all my money on books fairly early into the trip (read: at the first used bookstore we came across). So I put the CD back on the rack and pushed it to the back of my mind. However, in the last week, thanks to the miracle of Youtube, I've listened to the entire play. Several times. Non-stop since Thursday. Anyway.
I must say, I rather like most of it. There are several very excellent songs, my favorites being "Beauty Underneath", "Beneath a Moonless Sky" because I am, at the core, a hopeless romantic and this song reduced me to a quivering pile of shipper, "Devil Take the Hindmost" and the required over-10-minute finale, "Please, Miss Giry, I Want To Go Back" (clocking in at 14 minutes and change.)
Speaking of Miss Giry, in one of the more interesting aspects of this sequel more than half of the returning characters get a total character change. Raoul is a drunken, gambling loser, Meg takes over the Phantom's role as a jealous psychopath, while the Phantom becomes a family man. Being a total Christine/Eric shipper, I don't mind Raoul's transformation, because it justifies my pairing. However, I can see it not making much sense. The new Meg offers more emotional depth compared to her "Phantom" self, who is basically Christine's best friend, with no other major role. The one complaint I have about her character is the song "Bathing Beauty" which is repeated about four times over the course of the musical, and will get stuck in your head and never leave.
All in all, I liked the soundtrack to Love Never Dies (I have yet to see the play). I don't think it will ever match the brilliance of Phantom, but there are several fantastic new songs and characters. Recommended to all my fellow Phangirls and boys.